Final content of the web site,
www.edhca.net will remain in place until
its prepaid accounts for web hosting and domain registration expire.
These
comments are by past-president Paul Raveling. If it seems appropriate
in the future I may post some additional notes on my personal web site,
www.sierrafoot.org.
Here is the short summary of why we dissolved:
- A citizens alliance needs more citizens than we had as active participants.
- It is very difficult to influence public policy from the grass roots level.
- Group action has more limited maneuverability than individual action.
- EDHCA maintained a strict policy of avoiding partisan advocacy.
We
have a current situation which is appropriate for advocacy in a
partisan election, and our board members should be totally free to
participate in advocacy as private citizens tthis being perceived as a
Citizens Alliance position.
We
thank those who have supported us and worked with us. We achieved a few
modest successes for the benefit of our community, with future history
likely to show these as the top two:
- Supporting County staff
with local knowledge from an in-community perspective, leading to
redefinition of the El Dorado Hills Census Designated Place.
The
2010 Census will reflect the actual current scope of the EDH
community
area, which we estimate to include 42,000 to 43,000 residents. This
will replace the prior smaller area that contained only 18,016 people
in the 2000 Census, and will provide realistic demographic statistics
for future use. The expected results will be improved information for
public
policy planning and for the private sector. This should encourage
economic development in balance with our population, which will be
about 70,000 at buildout under current County land use planning.
- Supporting
the Capital Southeast Connector Joint Powers Authority at the staff
level, to initiate requirements analysis and conceptual design for
possible Connector alignments in the El Dorado Hills area.
The
Connector began as a SACOG planning project in 2002. We became aware of
it in 2005, and noted that its designation of White Rock Road as a
regional through route is very problematic for El Dorado Hills traffic
in the areas of Town Center, the Business Park, and the neighboring
residential areas. With additional support from the Four Seasons Civic
League, we appealed without success to the Connector JPA board of
directors. We finally established established communication at the JPA
staff level, and JPA staff has now begun examning the El Dorado Hills
issues. This has coupled into the beginnings of improved attention from
public agencies in Sacramento County and the City of
Folsom. Those agencies are essential as partners with El Dorado
County not only for considering Connector design, but
also for other potential arterial routes to serve our Business Park and
south-side
residential areas. This process has ultimate potential to reduce future
traffic congestion in central El Dorado Hills.
The
Connector example also
illustrates difficulty in functioning as a grass roots
organization. We moved from personal comments to a SACOG committee in
July, 2005
to Citizens Alliance and Four Seasons appeals to the JPA board in
subsequent years. We failed to have any impact at all at the JPA board
level. Some of us still have concerns about whether some of the board's
members
from Sacramento County understand El Dorado Hills-specific
circumsances, as well as the functional requirements of processes to
manage large engineering projects. A specific risk is confusing CEQA
environmental analysis with the totality of engineering processes.
El Dorado Hills has many additional challenges to
face, including some very old ones that are still unresolved. This is
very
difficult when our
local government is resident in Placerville, and it is additionally
difficult because that local government is responsible to others in the
County as well as to El Dorado Hills. Political situations often are
even more confounding due to the historic focus of power and
influence being mainly Placerville-based.
So where do we go from here?Past
Citizens Alliance directors and members of our loosely defined core
group will undoubtedly continue public advocacy, variously as
individuals or as members of organizations such as the Four Seasons
Civic League and the Bass Lake Action Committee. Much of this is issue-by-issue action.
El
Dorado Hills probably will see action on the framework for local
governance again in this new decade, and law provides only one such
framework for better local governance: Incorporation as a city. The largest lesson of Citizens
Alliance experience is that the current county-based system of
governance is not well-suited to our needs as an increasingly
urbanizing community. Some of us may contribute to such a new incorporation movement,
but any such effort probably will be guided by a completely new set of
community leaders.